<br />
<br />different. It's also no secret that HB 1516
<br />is state law, and everybody has to get used
<br />to the new order.
<br />Victor Gonzalez, CIO of the Texas De-
<br />partment of Agriculture, said he expects
<br />the consolidation to make life easier for
<br />him as the CIO of a state agency, though
<br />the picture is still a bit fuzzy.
<br />"Since it's in the beginning stages, the
<br />things that are in scope or out of scope
<br />_ meaning the things that will go to the
<br />[state] data center - are still being de-
<br />fined," Gonzalez said. "Until that's done,
<br />we're not certain whether our file servers,
<br />
<br />"The things that get a little hairier are
<br />file server and e-mail, calendaring and all
<br />those sorts of products, because you want
<br />to maintain flexibility in granting folder
<br />privileges, for example," Gonzales said.
<br />"Yet you want to make sure you're not pay-
<br />ing too much for that service."
<br />
<br />A Different DIR
<br />As agencies and the DIR create new
<br />working relationships, another interesting
<br />question the consolidation raises is what
<br />came first - HB 1516 or a new DIR?
<br />Olson took the job of both Texas CTO
<br />
<br />"Since it's in the beginning stages, the things that are in scope or out of
<br />scope - meaning the things that will go to the [state] data center - are
<br />still being defined." - Victor Gonzalez, CIO, Texas Department of Agriculture
<br />
<br />for example, have to go to the data center or
<br />whether it's just application-level servers."
<br />Gonzalez is part of an advisory commit-
<br />tee of state agency CIOs, which was created
<br />by the DIR to seek input on the consolida-
<br />tion process. That organization represents
<br />an important step, Gonzalez said, in easing
<br />the tension between agencies' traditional
<br />independence, and the DIR's new role and
<br />heightened level of authority.
<br />"Given that the legislation passed and
<br />there's new leadership at the D1R, people are
<br />less reluctant to try to participate:' he said.
<br />"Also, becauseoftheopenness with which the
<br />D1R is approaching things, that helps a lot.
<br />We're at the point where everybody realizes
<br />and recognizes that this is going to happen,
<br />and the more we contribute to that cause, the
<br />more control we'll have over what happens to
<br />every agency. ..
<br />
<br />Gonzalez said he's seen
<br />the DIR take a cautious
<br />approach to defining the
<br />consolidation's scope - an
<br />approach that's working well
<br />so far. In an ideal world, he
<br />said, agencies wouldn't care
<br />about the boxes and who
<br />managed them; and any-
<br />thing having to do with the
<br />agencies' business, such as
<br />applications and application
<br />development, would be man-
<br />aged by individual agencies.
<br />
<br />and executive director of the DIR in April
<br />2004. He had been out of the public sector
<br />for several years after serving as the first
<br />CIO of Pennsylvania from 1995 to 1999,
<br />where he orchestrated data-center consoli-
<br />dation and moved state agencies to a com-
<br />mon e-mail platform, among other cost-
<br />saving efforts.
<br />Pennsylvania reported saving $270 million
<br />in IT infrastructure expenditures because of
<br />consolidation efforts, Olson said in one of his
<br />first reports to the Texas Legislature - and
<br />Texas can save even more money.
<br />But the consolidation is about more than
<br />saving state government money, he said.
<br />"The biggest benefit is the ability for us
<br />to really strengthen our common efforts
<br />to build an IT enterprise for Texas," Olson
<br />said. "Once we start working closer togeth-
<br />er between agency and agency, that is the
<br />foundation that will allow us to move so
<br />much further as a state.
<br />"It's going to be the most long-term bene-
<br />fit," he continued. "In the past, agencies have
<br />worked together, but it's been on a piecemeal
<br />basis. HB 1516 moves us aggressively to that
<br />shared environment and common infrastruc-
<br />ture that's going to benefit everybody."
<br />Gonzalez said there's no question the
<br />DIR of 2005 is a different animal than the
<br />D1R he's observed over the five years he's
<br />worked for the Department of Agriculture.
<br />"The old DIR was there to provide stan-
<br />dards and guidance, but not really to get
<br />
<br />"?J
<br />'~l.
<br />
<br />into the business of IT for each agency,"
<br />Gonzalez explained. "This D I R- is like a
<br />more centralized IT department that actU-
<br />ally runs everybody else, which isn't neces-
<br />sarily a bad thing. It's just very different
<br />from what used to occur. Now, with HB
<br />1516 passing, the DIR has the authority to
<br />do a lot of the things it had been wanting
<br />to do - which is save the state money by
<br />consolidating IT."
<br />A piece of legislation like HB 1516,
<br />which clearly defines the D1R's sphere of
<br />influence, gives the department the nec-
<br />essary firepower to make things happen.
<br />The bill establishes a D1R different than
<br />its predecessor, while sending a message
<br />to other agencies that the Legislature is se-
<br />rious about IT consolidation, and is quite
<br />willing to give the DIR a big stick.
<br />That means a lot in Texas, observers say,
<br />because the Legislature wields substantial
<br />power. The governor's office is fairly weak
<br />in that no cabinet of department heads re-
<br />ports to the govern.or - because there is
<br />no cabinet - and governing boards over-
<br />see state agencies, giving them a large de-
<br />gree of independence.
<br />Still, Isett said the bill wouldn't have
<br />passed the Legislature if members weren't
<br />confident in Olson and the DIR, and ex-
<br />tremely frustrated with state agencies.
<br />"Everyone of these agencies, regardless
<br />of size, was running their own show," Is-
<br />ett said. "The question had to be asked: Do
<br />they have the resources internally to make
<br />good business decisions?"
<br />At first, Isett said, the Legislature had
<br />serious questions about the soundness of
<br />agencies' business cases for IT initiatives
<br />and purchases; the level of thought behind
<br />those initiatives; the degree of interaction,
<br />interoperability and compatibility between
<br />agencies' IT systems; and whether agencies
<br />could share databases or software services.
<br />"None of those questions were being
<br />asked on any IT purchases," he said. "We
<br />simply didn't have good control. and we
<br />didn't enter into good contracts. We're
<br />trusting D1R with a great responsibility,
<br />and historically, they haven't always dem-
<br />onstrated that that trust is well founded.
<br />But I think that under the current manage-
<br />ment, DIR has really shown it is ready to
<br />handle this kind ofresponsibility."
<br />
|