04/28/1994 MINUTES 6
MINUTES OF THE PARIS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
April 28, 1994
The Paris Economic Development Corporation met in a regular
meeting on Thursday, April 28, 1994, at 4:00 P.M., in the City
Hall, City Council Chambers, Paris, Texas. Chairman Philip R.
Cecil called the meeting to order with the following board
members present: Curtis Fendley, and Leon Williams. Also
present were ex-officio board members, Jo Ann Parkman, Ike
Jewett (representing Gary Cunningham) and Michael E. Malone,
City Manager.
Chairman Cecil made note that Board member Barney Bray was not
present at this time, but there was a quorum present.
Chairman Cecil stated at this point in the agenda he would like
to rearrange the order of the meeting. He said since Eric
Clifford had been appointed to the City Council to fill a
vacancy it was necessary that he resign his position on the
Board and that the City Council had appointed Mr. Dick Amis to
fill his position on this Board. He asked Judge Tom Hunt to
come forward and administer the oath of office to Mr. Amis.
After the oath was administered, Mr. Cecil officially welcomed
Mr. Amis to the Board.
27
Chairman Philip Cecil stated the next item on the agenda was
approval of the minutes from the previous meetings of the Paris
Economic Development Corporation. Chairman Cecil asked if
there were any corrections to the minutes of the previous
meetings, there being none, Board member Curtis Fendley made a
motion, seconded by Board member Leon Williams, to approve the
minutes as presented, and the motion was approved unanimously.
Chairman Cecil stated the next item on the agenda was the
financial report, and asked Mr. Gene Anderson, Finance Director
to go over this information. Mr. Anderson stated he had been
able to obtain an Employer's Identification Number from the
Internal Revenue Service which allowed him to set up a separate
bank account this past week. Mr. Anderson stated for the
allocation period ending February, 1994, the total payment to
the City was $284,708.30, including $1,450.12 interest to
date. He said this amount was transferred into an interest
bearing account which may cause this financial report in future
months to look slightly different than this one. Mr. Cecil
stated that the trend appeared to be, that routinely they
receive between $40,000.00 to $55,000.00 which lags two months
before it is actually received. Mr. Anderson said there are a
couple of months that will probably end up being an exception.
He said he could do a projection on the other months based on
the City's past history. Mr. Cecil stated he felt a projection
would be very helpful to the Board. Mr. Anderson said he will
be glad to do a projection month by month and have that at the
next meeting.
Mr. Cecil called for questions regarding the report. He said
if there were none, it would be appropriate for a motion to
have this report received. Board member Dick Amis made a
motion, seconded by Board member Curtis Fendley, to receive the
financial report as presented, and the motion was approved
unanimously.
Chairman Cecil advised the Board that Eric Clifford was
Secretary/Treasurer and was responsible for having the agenda
prepared each month as well as having a certain amount of
control over the funds, and this position needs to be filled.
He asked for nominations for election to the office of
Secretary/Treasurer. Board member Leon Williams nominated Dick
Amis for election to the position of Secretary/Treasurer, which
was seconded by Board member Curtis Fendley, and the motion was
approved unanimously. Mr. Cecil advised Mr. Amis that the
Corporation's Bylaws expand on the duties of
Secretary/Treasurer.
Chairman Cecil advised the Board regarding item no. 6 on the
agenda that the Pace Group was employed to accomplish some work
which included the Flexible Incentive Program and the Business
Retention Survey. He advised the Incentive Program was
presented to him in rough draft form earlier this week as well
as to Board member Fendley, and there were several items in the
information which needed to corrected and completed. He said
Brenda Schull was scheduled to be at this meeting to go over
this information, and they have asked to be excused from this
meeting. He said they would like to appear before this Board
on Thursday, May 12, 1994 at 4:00 P.M. to present the Program.
He had asked them to be at the regularly scheduled meeting in
May, but Mr. Lovorn could not be here on that date and May 12,
1994, would be the most convenient time for him to be here.
Board member Williams stated he would not be able to be here at
that time. Mr. Cecil asked the other members of the Board, and
they said May 12th was fine with them. Mr. Cecil said if the
date was good for Mr. Bray as well, he felt they would go ahead
and try to set the meeting date for May 12, 1994, because it
would probably be June before Mr. Lovorn could be available
again. Mr. Williams said that was fine with him.
29
stated the point is that those peple, other than the overtime,
would be part of the City's budget anyway unless you employed
them because of this job. Mr. Malone said other than the
overtime and the equipment rental that is true.
City Engineer Smith stated the total of those two invoices are
$135,640.53. Mr. Smith said at that point in time the City had
flow re-established to the plant which also services Kimberly
Clark at that point. He said Kimberly Clark's lift station
discharges into the manhole next to the driveway at B & W where
the salaried employees park. He said this whole line from the
highway to the lift station is serving Kimberly Clark, B & W,
and Southwest Foundry. Mr. Malone said under the present
environmental regulations the discharge from plants like B & W
and Campbell's Soup have been improved significantly. He said,
in fact, what has happened to this line is, that probably in
years prior to the type regulations we are under now with
industrial pretreatment orders, the actual damage to the line
was probably due to the input of the plant into the line. He
said normally when someone damages your equipment you would go
back to them. He said this has been much the same case we have
had with other industries in Paris because at one time there
was not really any real regulations. He said had these type
materials not ever been introduced into the system the line
would probably have held for many more years.
Chairman Cecil asked if the line served any residential
customers. Mr. Smith said yes, that the line proceeds on up to
Brown Avenue and stops around Washington Street. Chairman
Cecil said it would be accurate to say then that for the most
part this line is used for industrial use, and Mr. Smith agreed.
Mr. Smith said before they started this line he applied normal
engineering techniques looking at areas served and estimated
how much flow could be generated from a plant. He said that is
how he determined it would be prudent to use a 15" line. He
said he could not see going back with an 8" line and then they
would not be able to do anything with it if someone wanted to
site another industry in that area. He said the line is
oversized with a lot extra capacity. He said the project still
lacks clean up and the flow still needs to be reversed on
approximately 100 ft. of sewer to make it work more properly.
He said there still exists on the south side of the railroad
tracks approximately 800 ft. of the 8" concrete pipe, and it is
the same type we had this problem with which needs replacing.
Mr. Smith said they are going to try to wait until summer to
finish the rest of the project.
Chairman Cecil asked City Manager Malone and City Engineer
Smith what specifically their request was. City Manager Malone
stated the City is asking for reimbursement to the Water and
Sewer Funds where the money came from which included the
approximate $99,000.00 plus the invoices from Public Works
Department. Mr. Malone also said when the City completes the
project in the summer which would be labelled Phase II they
would come back to the Corporation at that time.
31
Chairman Cecil said he felt it was appropriate for this board
to take some action, but the question was how much action to
take. City Manager Malone advised the normal duties and the
administrative order makes it important that we utilize every
means possible to keep the rate structure lower, and the fact
that the City has subsidized Kimberly Clark over $200,000.00
during the last three year period. He said that was money
proposed in the rate structure where a rate not recommended by
the consultant was adopted and has caused a problem. He said
he felt that was the sort of thing which needs to be addressed
with the economic development sales tax. He said the City
would not submit an invoice to the Corporation that is not of a
conservative nature. Mr. Malone clarified the fact that the
City subsidized the rate structure for Kimberly Clark and they
did so to the detriment of providing service for the system. He
said that money was not recovered through other rates, and it
will now be passed on to the residential rate payers and other
commercial customers in this rate study. Mr. Malone stated we
are in a serious situation with both our Water and Wastewater
System because we failed to recover adequate revenues to fund
the repairs and regulatory requirements that have been placed
on the City. He said if he had not felt that the City would
recover these funds and for the planned course of work, then he
would have done it under an emergency basis by hiring outside
contractors entirely.
Board member Amis made a motion, seconded by Board member
Fendley, to reimburse the City of Paris the cost of this
project which includes the $99,264.78 actual cost of the
vendors and private contractors accrued up to this point, plus
the $36,375.75 for the Public Works invoices for a total of
$135,640.53, which carried unanimously.
City Manager Malone asked if the Board was going to have the
regular meeting next month as well and Chairman Cecil said yes,
that the only agenda item for the May 12, 1994, agenda was the
receipt of the report from the Pace Group.
Board member Fendley questioned if the bids were in on the
Campbell Soup Road Project. City Manager Malone asked City
Engineer Smith to give them some background on the Campbell
Soup Road Project. Mr. Smith said they have called the project
Soup Street Paving Project, and the bids are to be opened on
May 3, 1994. He said Hilliard & Sons, Jerry Bob Stephens and
Drake Construction have picked up plans. Mr. Smith said they
the expected this project to run around $135,000.00 to
$155,000.00 with a 12" reinforced concrete pavement thirty-nine
feet wide. He said the projectstarts at the edge of the
pavement on Hwy 271 and proceeds to the back of Campbell Soup
Plant and stops at the east right-of-way line of the railroad
tracks. He said there will be a temporary routing accomplished
at the north property line of the J10 property. He said they
are going to put in a temporary culvert and a driveway using
three inch flexible base so the truck traffic can be maintained
to Campbell Soup.
32
Chairman Cecil asked about the length of time to complete this
project. City Engineer Smith said he put in the project 90
days to substantially completion which means the project will
be useable in 120 days. Mr. Cecil asked if this project will
be one that requires one payment at the end of the project.
Mr. Smith said no, when a project exceeds $100,000.00, the law
requires that it be bonded. He said whoever they award the
project to will have to furnish the statutory limits on Workers
Compensation, liability insurance, a performance bond which
guarantees they will build the job, and a payment bond which
guarantees payment to subcontractors and suppliers. Board
member Amis asked a question about our payout or the City's
payout to that company. Mr. Smith said he would anticipate
partial payments on the job, monthly partial payments. City
Manager Malone stated originally the City had planned to do
this as an in-house project supervised by the Engineer,
foregoing any bonding requirements and probably the time frame
would have been a lot quicker.
Chairman Cecil stated one thing the Board has to keep in mind
and that is they have approximately $284,000.00 and they have
just authorized spending approximately $136,000.00 leaving
approximately $148,000.00. He questioned City Manager as to
the payment of Day & Associates. Mr. Malone stated no,
P.E.D.C. has not reimbursed Day & Associates for funds paid
because they have not gotten all the information together on
that amount. He said the reason they have moved so quickly on
the B & W Project, even though it is not complete, is because
we are in a situation where there is no activity going on in
the collection system, and he has had to make a quarterly
report to the E.P.A.
Chairman Cecil reminded the board that the Campbell Soup
Project is coming up as well as the B & W Phase II Sewer
Project and they probably want to operate on a current basis.
Board member Amis questioned City Manager Malone that along
with the Day & Associates bill is there going to be another
City appropriation of time like we saw in the B & W Sewer
Project Phase I. City Manager Malone said yes, that there
would be another bill. Mr. Amis said he would like to see the
issue of the straight time, overtime policy addressed.
Chairman Cecil asked for Mr. Malone to expand on this. City
Manager Malone stated that the bylaws provide for payment for
the services the City provides such as secretarial, mailing
letters, City Attorney's time, etc. He said the City will have
very conservative estimates. He said the City felt that at
some point in time there will be less demand on the City
particularly in light of the fact we hope to have an Economic
Developer/Chamber Manager. He said the Board also has to
remember as that change occurs there will probably be requests
from the Chamber of Commerce to pay. He said he felt the City
was more concerned with staff time such as secretaries, clerks
and any materials purchased such as the notebooks which came
out of a budget which the City did not have. Chairman Cecil
asked when the City planned to submit these expenses. Mr.
Malone said they are not in a hurry, and that they are in the
Summer season when they can make their most productive gains.
He said he is very concerned about some other things they need
to be doing with budgeting coming up for the City as well
Chairman Cecil said in regards to Mr. Amis' question, any time
we use City employees, for example, taking the minutes, City
Manager and City Attorney's attendance, the Board is going to
have to pay for that, and he feels that is appropriate. City
Manager Malone advised the City is going to take a conservative
approach to the cost as economic development is an area of
concern to City government.
3
Chairman Cecil asked for other items concerning the Board
members. Board member Leon Williams asked how close they are
to hiring an Economic Development/Chamber Manager. Ex Officio
Board member Parkman said they had been checking references on
a couple of the applicants and they would be meeting in the next
few days to see if they could come to a consensus. She stated
they have had some good applicants, and have not had to use the
Pace Group as of this date.
Chairman Cecil asked if there was any other business and there
being none, he declared the board meeting recessed until the
special meeting to be held on Thursday, May 12, 1994, at 4:00
P.M.
CHAIRMAN, PHILIP R. CECIL
ATTEST:
ASSISTANT CITY CLERK, BARBARA DENNY