11/15/2016 MINUTESHOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF PARIS
REGULAR MEETING
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS MEETING
100 GEORGE WRIGHT HOMES
MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 15, 2016
Present at the Meeting:
Gary Savage — Chairman of the Board of Commissioners
TK Haynes —Vice Chairman of the Board of Commissioners
Brenda Cherry — Commissioner of the Board of Commissioners
Dewayne Dangerfield — Commissioner of the Board of Commissioners
Sally Ruthart — Executive Director /PHA
Patricia Pridemore —Program Manager /PHA
Kim Snow — Inspector /PHA
Kelly Crawford — Social Service Coordinator /PHA
Sharon Reynerson — Guest — Lone Star Legal Aid Attorney
Brent Higgins — Guest — Lone Star Legal Aid Assistant
1. Meeting called to order at 12:39 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2016 by Chairman of the Board
of Commissioners, Gary Savage.
2. Having four Board members present, a quorum, Mr. Savage thanked and welcomed everyone to
the meeting.
3. Citizen's Forum opened. No one chose to speak. Citizen's Forum closed.
4. Minutes from the September 20, 2016 meeting— Minutes were approved with a motion made
by Dewayne Dangerfield and seconded by TK Haynes. Passed 4 -0.
5. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: None.
6. NEW BUSINESS:
A. Presentation by Sally Ruthart, Executive Director, on status of or items to act upon:
d. Moved this item to top due to the fact that Mark Meltnicenko from Abacus was
waiting by the phone for our call to answer any questions that we may have
regarding the mold testing on units 403, 404, 413, and 414 George Wright Homes.
413 GWH, Ms. Hawkins was moved on Friday after we received the report on
Tuesday. The report stated that there was a possible mold source at that unit. The
PHA plans to gut the entire unit and treat the interior studs and floors, duct work,
remove cabinets, and treat the entire unit. Ms. Cherry had questions for Mark so we
called him on the phone. Ms. Cherry stated that unit 413 was tested by Abacus back
in 2010 and it was found to have toxic mold. She asked if the toxic mold just goes
away by itself. Mark stated no. Mark also stated that we tested it last month and
found that it has been painted but it is still there. Ms. Cherry asked if it was still
toxic. Mark stated that it is not at a toxic level but it is something that you want to
address, relocate the tenant and clean the unit up. Mr. Ruthart explained that we
had already relocated her and are going to completely gut the unit. Ms. Cherry
stated that she didn't understand that if it was toxic before does it just go away.
Mark explained that it was painted over. Mark also answered Ms. Cherry's question
and said that it does not go away, it keeps growing. Ms. Ruthart asked Mark if paint
seals it. Mark stated that yes it does, but it can come back. Mark explained that this
time there was no visible mold. Ms. Cherry asked him if he used any machines to
test this unit. Mark explained that he did use machines that test air quality and
surface mold. He also told Ms. Cherry that he was the inspector from the 2010 mold
test and that the mold was visible at the 2010 inspection but it was not visible at
this latest inspection, but there was an elevated level in the air samples. No other
questions for Mark, Ms. Ruthart explained to Mark that the PHA was going to go
further than his recommendations (remove carpet and clean ductwork) and
completely gut the unit, treat the interior studs and flooring, and clean ductwork.
Mark stated that would be good as the unit was in disarray. And, if we wanted to
retest the unit when all the work was done that he would be glad to come and
retest. Ms. Ruthart agreed that retesting needed to be done and she would contact
him. Ms. Ruthart thanked Mark for his time and the call was disconnected. Mr.
Savage asked if we were talking about ripping out the sheetrock. Ms. Ruthart
explained that we are ripping out sheetrock, cabinets, tub, sinks, all of it. Mr. Savage
stated that this should take care of what was painted over. Ms. Ruthart stated that
hopefully it would take care of it. Mr. Haynes stated that surely the window sills
were cleaned with bleach or some other chemical before they were painted. Ms.
Ruthart stated that she did not know if that was done. Ms. Cherry stated that bleach
would not take care of the mold. Mr. Haynes stated that it was in the report that it
would take care of it. Ms. Cherry also asked about another tenant that was moved
because of mold. Ms. Ruthart stated that yes Dr. Jones was moved from 107 and
there was no mold found behind the sheetrock and hopefully this is what they find
in 413. Ms. Cherry asked in the future what would be the procedure for tenants that
find mold in their apartment. Ms. Ruthart stated that the PHA would probably call
Mark and have the unit tested but if there is a lot of visible mold that the PHA would
probably do the same as we did for Ms. Hawkins at 413 and just move them. Ms.
Reynerson asked if she could say something and Ms. Ruthart told her she would
have to get that approved from Mr. Savage. Mr. Savage allowed Ms. Reynerson to
speak and she told the Board that the earlier report stated that the mold was
caused by the single pane windows and the gas heat. She also stated that the report
said that if the windows weren't changed that the mold would come back. Ms.
Ruthart stated that there was nothing about that in this report. Ms. Cherry stated
that she was going to bring a copy of the 2010 report so that everyone could see it
and we could stop talking about the report that only she has a copy of. Mr. Savage
asked her to email the report to him and Ms. Ruthart so that it could be distributed
before the next meeting. Ms. Cherry stated that she would email it to Ms. Ruthart
for distribution to the other Board Members. Ms. Ruthart asked for more questions
or suggestions from the Board as she is welcoming any help with this problem. Ms.
Cherry asked that this be put on the next agenda after everyone has had a chance to
look at the 2010 report from 413 GWH. Board agreed to add it to the next agenda.
a. Occupancy report — report shows 8 vacancies but it is actually about 12 due to the
opening of the Section 8 waiting list due to the fact that if you live in Public Housing,
according to our A &O policy, you are adequately housed and do not qualify for
Section 8. The Section 8 Waiting List will be opening on Wednesday, November 16th
at 8 am. Flyers were put in the newspaper, website, doors, and all over town. 284
currently on the Section 8 program with 15 out looking. Our Section 8 Voucher
number is 293. Constant effort to keep the numbers up. Ms. Cherry stated that the
numbers at Booker T Washington looks like the PHA is segregating. Ms. Cherry
stated that since Booker T is the most undesirable of all the housing authority she
doesn't understand why it is more black people than any other site or on Section 8.
Ms. Ruthart stated that the PHA cannot control who applies for Section 8 and that
the applications /waiting list are time and date of application. Ms. Cherry states that
when you look at the numbers at Booker T that it looks like segregation. Ms. Cherry
states that she doesn't know why but that it looks like that. Mr. Savage agreed that
the charts would make you come to that conclusion.
b. New recording equipment purchased. A copy of the meetings can be given to you if
you bring a zip drive, a recording of the meeting can be transferred to your zip drive
now.
c. Financial — MD &A attached in Board member packets. Much easier to read and
gives more details of financial status.
Section 8 waiting list will open on Wednesday, November 16. Kim Snow and Sally
Ruthart will be at the PHA office at 4 am to hand out numbered cards to keep
everyone from congregating. This has worked well in the past.
Energy Audit — is being performed as we speak. Energy audits are not due but every
5 years and the PHA's is due in 2017. This is a report to make things more energy
efficient for the tenants.
e. Admission & Occupancy Policy and Administrative Policy to be amended. Some
changes are mandatory per HUD and some are optional. The PHA is thinking about
adding preferences for Veterans and Kids aging out of Foster Care. The PHA is also
planning on adding a fee for landlords who tell us a unit is ready and it is not near
ready. EID will change from 48 months to 24 months. URP's will be paid quarterly
instead of monthly if they are under 10 dollars per month. Biennial HQS inspections
are possible. 120% of FMR for handicap accessible units. HQS units must have
central heat and air systems. The deduction for elderly and disabled family's
deduction will increase to 525 from 480. Medical deductions percentage will
increase to 10% of income. Fixed income families can be recertified every 2 or 3
years. New student definition.Grievance procedure selecting a hearing officer.
Community Self certification requirement.
B. Ms. Cassandra Hearn was absent from the meeting. This will be added to the agenda for
next months meeting.
7. No resolutions.
8. Board Questions: Ms. Cherry asked about the Resident Council how they are appointed.
Kelly Crawford answered her questions stating that they are nominated by other residents.
There is a constant problem of getting residents to be on the Council. They think it is a big
problem however, it is actually an honor. Ms. Cherry suggested that forms be sent out to all
residents and Ms. Crawford agreed that it is a good idea and she will do that. Ms.Cherry asked
how many are on the committee. Ms. Crawford stated that they currently have four but need
five.
9. No further business or questions, a motion for adjournment was made by Ms. Cherry and
seconded by Dewayne Dangerfield. Motion passed 4 -0. Meeting was adjourned at 1:37 pm.
APPROVED THIS DAY OF , 2016,
T K Haynes, - Vice Chairman
Sally Ruthart, Secretary