04-A Historic Pres Com Min 11-28-05
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING
CITY OF PARIS HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
CITY HALL WEST ANNEX
CONFERENCE ROOM
150 1ST STREET S.E.
PARIS. TEXAS
MONDAY. NOVEMBER 28. 2005
4:00 O'CLOCK P.M.
1. The Historic Preservation Commission meeting was called to order by
Chairman Arvin Starrett at 4:00 P.M.
A. The following members were present:
Barbara Wilson, Vice Chairman
Jerry Raper
Paul Denney
Sue Lancaster
Ann Rogers, Secretary
Alternate: Claudia Hunt
The following members were absent:
Alternates: Brian Wear
Becki Norment
B. Also present were Lisa Wright, Historic Preservation Officer; Bethany
Golden, Main Street Coordinator; Charles Richards, The Paris News;
and Suzy Harper.
2. Approve minutes from previous meetings. Motion to approve the minutes as
amended from the November 9, 2005, meeting was made by Sue Lancaster,
seconded by Barbara Wilson. Motion carried 7-0.
3. Consideration of and action on the following Certificates of Appropriateness:
A. 28 ~ Plaza. Michelle's Craft Supplies by Alex Pickering, Designated
Agent. Alex Pickering stated that the colors presented were the same
as ones previously approved with a red band. The border will be a gold
leaf with scroll work. Motion was made to approved the COA by
Barbara Wilson, seconded by Sue Lancaster. Motion carried 7-0.
B. 574 Church Street · Kelly and Melissa Wickersham. Melissa
Wickersham wants to replace wood balcony rail and column with
wrought iron. The bottom columns were set too far back. Mr. Starrett
advised Ms. Wickersham that all residences in the Church/South Main
- . r .
Historic District use SOl standards for rehabilitation. Mr. Starrett stated
that the Board is hard-pressed to consider the application for a of
certificate of appropriateness because the alterations are not minor and
not ordinary maintenance. The proposed application would be
changing the architectural style of the building; therefore, the
application could not be honored. However, Mr. Starrett stated that he
would be glad to look at other proposals if the other Board members
feel the same as he does. With the proposed changes, six standards
are violated. Motion was made to deny the COA by Jerry Raper,
seconded by Barbara Wilson. Motion carried 6-1.
Arvin Starrett advised Ms. Wickersham that she could appeal to the City
Councilor come back before the Historic Commission with a different
plan. Ms. Wickersham was advised that Paul Denney could offer
suggestions on structural materials.
----- CONSENT AGENDA -----
[Items appearing on this consent agenda may be approved by a single
vote of the Commission, with such approval applicable to aI/ items
appearing on said agenda. If any Commission member desires to
discuss and consider separately any item appearing on the consent
agenda, that Commission member may do so by requesting that the
item be removed from the consent agenda and considered as a
separate item.}
4. Discussion of and possible action regarding the fol/owing structures
considered by code inspectors to be in violation of Article 11/ of Chapter 7 of
the Code of Ordinances of the City of Paris, Paris, Texas, entitled
IISubstandard and Dangerous Buildings and Structures," to determine
whether such buildings or structures can be rehabilitated and designated on
the National Register of Historic Places, as a recorded Texas Historic
Landmark, or as historic property as designated by the City Council of the
City of Paris:
A. 1030 Park Street
B. 1025 Park Street
C. 1231 5th Street N. W.
D. 1020 28th Street N.W.
E. 1010 28th Street N.W.
F. 2885 Colvin Street
..- ....r..
G. 2875 Colvin Street
H. 2265 W. Campbell
I. 1024 7 1/2 Street N.E.
J. 549 8th Street N.E.
K. 1029 4th Street N.E.
L. 910 3rd Street N.E.
M. 766 3rd Street N.E.
N. 425 2nd Street N.E.
O. 758 1st Street N.E.
P. 403 1st Street N.E.
Q. 333 1st Street N.E.
R. 401 3rd Street S. W.
S. 990 W. Henderson
T. 1019 3rd Street S.E.
U. 301 E. Jackson
V. 655 Graham Street
W. 2720 Lamar Avenue (1029 Collegiate Drive - corner of Lamar and
Collegiate)
----- END CONSENT AGENDA -----
Motion to pull 4.J from the list was made by Barbara Wilson, seconded by
Paul Denney. Motion carried 7-0.
Motion to pull 4.0 from the list and hold for 90 days was made by Paul
Denney, seconded by Sue Lancaster because there may be an opportunity to
move to historic site. Motion carried 7-0.
Motion to pull 4.R from the list was made by Paul Denney, seconded by
..- .....r
Claudia Hunt, and the City will seek an administrative search warrant. Motion
carried 7-0.
Motion was made by Sue Lancaster, seconded by Paul Denney, for others to
be referred to the Building and Standards Commission for demolition since
they cannot be rehabilitated nor do they have significant historical value.
Motion carried 7-0.
5. Discussion of and possible action on the grand opening ceremony for the
new City Council Chambers. According to the newspaper, the ribbon cutting
and open house will be December 2, 2005, at 5:00 p.m.; however, the
Commission requested that the ribbon cutting be moved back. Since Paul
Denney will be out of town on certain dates, December 9 was selected.
6. Discussion of and possible action on appointing a Pocket Park Fund-raising
Committee. Arvin Starrett stated that Historic Preservation Board members
should not act as fund raising committee. Main Street could be in charge of
the fund raiser and select a couple of members from HPC to assist.
7. Receipt of report from the Historic Preservation Officer. The HPO handed out
the attached report.
8. Request items from Board for future agendas. None.
9. The meeting adjourned at 4:35 p.m.
APPROVED THIS 14TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2005.
Arvin Starrett, Chairman
.. --.--....--'1'"'.-.'''..........' -,
1::
c 0
o CI)
;:;~
ns U)
~ ~
Q) ...
tn J!
Cl)fn
...
0..
(.)
'i: c
o ;;
... u
.! CI)
:I: 0
...
a.
c
o
..
CJ
~
~
II)
II)
!
't:I
't:I
c(
e: e: ro Q)
00_.c:
t5 Qd:~ -.
rotl..c"Oe:
o Q)::J Q).-
e: -:;; III .2: U
'" 0 Q) n
e:E-o.....
~ ._ ~ ~ I
.c: Q)
j!l Ol~ III ....0
.... e: ..... '-_
~:og1ij~
o5iECi
III III "- e:
III .c: 0 .-
ro~Ole:E
.c: = .5 _ R
...."- > - .....
Q) ~.- Q)
e:- 01 ...0
~ ."-- e: =
o - .... co .-
oQ)-~
~ e ..0 a.
Q) Q) E e: e:
Q) Q)'-
a.:5 0 = :!2
e e: Q) ";:: '5
Q.oO~..c
00
::J
-
co
en
~
co
Q)
.c:
01
e:
.;::
::J
"0
"0
Q)
00
a.
..!!1
(5
o
0>
e:
'Ocri
=e:
::J'-
al~
Ul.9~
0> ro
c s... 'C
"c ,Q 2
Q) .... ro
a.a.E
0<(
Q)QQ)
:5u:5
a.ro"O
::J e:
"O~co
Q) ij:: .
"O_1Il
....Oro
~ e:';::
..0"02 .
III "- ro "0
co"OE2
.c: Q) ,5
.... .c: Q) ro
Q) .c:
e: --
~(j)o>o
o > e: e:
Q).- Q)
Q) ~ 0 ....
.c:ocoQ)
I-.c:Ci~
l!?
o
o III "0
"O_Q)
"Oe:-
e:~{g
co 01"-
IIlroa.
~ ;:,:m III
~ ..0 "0_ t5
e: III Ill";::
.- III - ..0
~ Q) 5i
e: 0 E e:
Q) 0 ._
a.coQ)=
0~Q)~
-0Q) .
ro=.c:
(j)co-o
~1U-ge:
CI):5co~
-
Q)
~
-
CI)
E
ro
.I::.
e:
o
al
e:
'm
:E
en
o
co
N
- e:
e: 0
Q),-
1Il-
a.
e: 0
~ ffi co
..coe:
IIle:E
co III ro
.c: ,- ~
.... g><(
Q).-
=.... "
Q)Q)ro
-:5>
:>,coo
1Il~ E
Q) e: Q)
1::ro....
::J ....
00le:
01Ut;
"O:5Q)
e: 0> ::J
o e:
0.- Q)
Q) III ....
1Il'S; "0
<("Oe:
ro ro
"01:: 1Il:!-' III
Q)::Jcoe:~
~O.I::.IIlQ)cri
.- 0 Q) Q) ::J
1:: "00=>0
Q)........"O:>-
ooro C')
ro'+'-O....Q)E
'S 01 e: ~ .I::. ~
'E .5 ~ ~ -;, -
Q)'5....0::J1Il
Ill.... 0lQ) Q)E
e: Q).c:~::J
Q)=.c:-co(j)
Q)col-_-....
..0..0 -e:
III ro Q)
co Q)~.. og
.c::5coQ):!::lt:
Q) Ill:>' ..: Q
01ll1ll~Q)_
:;::::;1::Q)O=OO
o co 0 ro Q) 0
e:ii)Q)..c-Q.
e:_e:Q)j!?Q)
2co~E-::::5
co:5 -OOQ)
- e:o_....
,Q = .Q e: 0
> co - - 0>-
<( E ~ g 'w ~
III
e:
e:
<(
u
..--
o
C')
~
CI)
(j)
~
-
CI)
e:
.9
III
::J
o
I
W
LO
..--
N
-
III
..--
LO
o
C')
.-T-