02-B Historic Pres Com Min 12-19-06
MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING
CITY OF PARIS HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
CITY OF PARIS
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
107 E. KAUFMAN
PARIS. TEXAS
MONDAY. DECEMBER 19. 2005
12:00 O'CLOCK P.M.
1. The Historic Preservation Commission meeting was called to order by
Chairman Arvin Starrett at 12:01 P.M.
A. The following members were present:
Barbara Wilson, Vice Chairman
Jerry Raper
Paul Denney
Sue Lancaster
Brian Wear
Alternate: Becki Norment
The following members were absent:
Ann Rogers, Secretary
Alternates: Claudia Hunt
B. Also present were Lisa Wright, Historic Preservation Officer; Bethany
Golden, Main Street Coordinator.
2. Approve minutes from previous meetings. Motion to approve the minutes as
is from the November 28, 2005, meeting was made by Sue Lancaster,
seconded by Jerry Raper. Motion carried 7-0.
3. Consideration of and action on the following Certificates of Appropriateness:
A. 643 Church Street. William Elliott. Trey Elliott was not present. Arvin
Starrett had questions regarding the setback. Based on the fence
being 90' from curbside, motion was made to approve the COA by Brian
Wear, seconded by Barbara Wilson. Motion carried 7-0.
B. 135 Lamar Avenue. Karol Lyn and Hunter Moore. Karol Lyn Moore
proposed placing an 85" sign one brick below the top detail with a 45
degree angle on the corner. It will have a brushed metal finish with
LED light behind the lettering. Paul Denney advised the Commission
that the drawing for the sign was made by Denney Architects, but no
money was exchanged. Chairman Starrett added that Paul Denney
would be allowed to vote on the COA. Motion was made to approve by
Barbara Wilson, seconded by Becki Norment. Motion carried 7-0.
C. 124 N. Main Street - Paul Denney. Motion was made to recuse Paul
Denney from consideration of this COA by Barbara Wilson, seconded
by Jerry Raper. Motion carried 6-0.
Paul Denney stated that he may close on the building on December 31
and put in a loft apartment. This is Phase I to secure the building. The
sales contract requires for the work to be done in 6 months. Paul's first
priority is to redo the front of the building and bring it up to 501
standards. Enclosed in the packet are several pictures and Phase I
scope of work. Also included is a proposed layout for the front
windows. Mr. Denney is asking for approval of the preliminary design
concept. The design concept has to be presented to the seller and it
could change. There are two different door designs. Mr. Denney would
like approval for both options so that he can present that to the seller
of the property. Motion was made to approve the COA by Sue
Lancaster, seconded by Brian Wear. Motion carried 7-0.
Motion was made by Barbara Wilson, seconded by Jerry Raper for Paul
Denney to return to the meeting. Motion carried 6-0.
D. 2 Clarksville Street, 6 Clarksville Street, and 115 S. Main Street. Becki
Norment. Motion was made to recuse Becki Norment by Brian Wear,
seconded by Barbara Wilson. Motion carried 6-0.
Becki Norment stated that she sent photos to the Texas Main Street for
their ideas and suggestions for the facade. Enclosed in the packet
were the pictures and response of Main Street. A drawing by the
contractor, Aaron Raper, was handed out. Ms. Norment decided to
leave the inset as is. The plexiglass will be replaced with plain glass.
Ms. Norment is seeking approval only on the west side of the building.
The front and side will not need to match since they are two different
buildings. Motion was made to approve the COA by Jerry Raper,
seconded by Paul Denney. Motion carried by a vote of 6-0.
Consideration of the canopy, on the west side only, will come later.
Motion for Becki Norment to return to the meeting was made by Paul
Denney, seconded by Brian Wear. Motion carried 6-0.
----- CONSENT AGENDA -----
[Items appearing on this consent agenda may be approved by a single
vote of the Commission, with such approval applicable to all items
appearing on said agenda. If any Commission member desires to
discuss and consider separately any item appearing on the consent
agenda, that Commission member may do so by requesting that the
item be removed from the consent agenda and considered as a
separate item.}
4. Discussion of and possible action regarding the following structures
considered by code inspectors to be in violation of Article III of Chapter 7 of
the Code of Ordinances of the City of Paris, Paris, Texas, entitled
IISubstandard and Dangerous Buildings and Structures," to determine
whether such buildings or structures can be rehabilitated and designated on
the National Register of Historic Places, as a recorded Texas Historic
Landmark, or as historic property as designated by the City Council of the
City of Paris:
A. 239 2nd Street N.E.
B. 1613 S. Main Street
C. 1567 S. Main Street
D. 1545 S. Main Street
E. 18 W. Hearne Street
F. 253 2nd Street N.E.
----- END CONSENT AGENDA -----
No items were pulled from the consent agenda. Motion was made by Barbara
Wilson, seconded by Jerry Raper, for Items 4A thru 4F to be referred to the
Building and Standards Commission for demolition since they cannot be
rehabilitated nor do they have significant historical value. Motion carried 7-0.
5. Discussion of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties. This item is being used as an information only item today.
Handouts were distributed for the members to refresh their memory for
discussion at the next meeting.
6. Receipt of report from the Historic Preservation Officer. Lisa Wright handed
out the attached report.
7. Request items from Board for future agendas. None.
8. The meeting adjourned at 12:30 p.m.
APPROVED THIS 11TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2006.
Arvin Starrett, Chairman
r
I... 0) . ro 0>"0 (/)e:{ "":"0 O)e:{
0) .c ~"O c:: c:: ro .- 0) .c
c::.....0)c:: :1Q lo ~ajo lo > .....
~.= E 0) E 0 0> c:( .
lo'- >C::0)0~ "OE C::Oe:{
a. ..... ro "0 0 (/)J2 ~~ .Qua
0)0)'0 lo+-c::a.c:: lOlOu
.c1...0) ..... a. 0 .- t~
..... O.~ ~ ~ 0 Q..~ .~ 0) 0 ~.....lo
.....0) (/) (/)- o c:: o :J
o 0) 0 c:: c::0)::..... lo 0 c::
.....-O)lo (/)rol...1i)c:: lo (/) -.c .-
:J1..."j lo 0) .- lo a. ~ 1i)
....."0.....0) ~OO~(/) ~.c c:: ~ 0)
C::0)0.c I...C::ZloC:: ~~ 0) 0> :J
O).cc::.....
(/) 0 c:: 0) (/) (/) 0) 0) c::
(/).~ 0 t: ._ c:: 0) (/) 0) .0 .- 0)
~ ....: 0>.0 (/)a. 0) :2 I...
c:: c:: 0) 0) looo > .- .....
0)0)(/).0 0> ro .- (/) ro :J c::
O)t:c::_ ~.!: > (/) ro ~ 5..w .c::.oO)
.0 'C 0 :: 0) I... OO).c:: O)O)U) 0) (/)
(/)~~~ ~~~.s~ .2.c::O (/) .c:: c::
..... ..... ~""'O)
ro lo 0) ~ o lo I... "0 .- 0.......J :J ..... 0)
..... c:: ..... c::ou .....0.0
.c I...:J o'OO>loo c:: I...
O>lo..... ><
"OC::c:: c:: o 0) .- 0) (/)
I... .!: 0 ....."0
O)..........:J C::lO:tJ"OC:: ~~c 0>.- ro
(/)- I... o I... (/) 0) 0 c::(/).c
t: 0) ..... o 0> 0) .~ :tJ - 0'- +-.c::1...
O):J . (/) O).....:JO)lO .Q 0) (/)
- .....(/) .c::t:O)
0"0._ (/)roO"O(5 > .c:: 0) .Ql 0 i
e:{0)0.c e:{ .c 0) 0) .- e:{1-.s
1...1........ .....1...1...> ..JC::_
>, ~
0
> o (/)"0
't lo
0) "0.....0)
0 .c "Oc::.....
C c:: ~ lo
C 0> lo 0>:2
0 CI) 0 c:: (/)loa.
.- a:: ;= 'C > lo
..., :J ~ >,:: (/)
as CJ "0
U) ~ O.o"O~
~ "0 "0 .0
:J 0) c:: (/) (/)'C (/)
.. (/) .- (/) ......0
(I) ~ 0) c:: (/) 0)
J! a. 0) c:: c:: I...
rn J2 c:: 0 E c:: :J
en 0) 0 .- .....
G) (5 a.lOO)= .~
... 0 0~Q)J!! 0) LL
C. 0> -00) - I...
(/) c:: ~=.c::
to) :J "O(/) O)ro..... 0
.....
.- lo :: c:: >.....'0 c::
... ..... :J'- 0) lo c:: lo
0 U) al~ U).slo 0 ..J
...,
rn
.- ..... .....
I: 0) ~ 0)
~ ~
en ..... U) c:: .....
en U) ..... 0 U)
0) .....
G) E c:: ~ (/) E
.. :J
'C lo lo ..... 0 lo
'C .c ~ U) :c .c
<C c:: ..... c::
0 (/) 0
al U) ~ W al
e:{ ~ 0 L{) L{) L{)
0 co 0 ~ (l')
u (l') N (l') N ~