2004-165-RES ESTABLISHING GUIDELINES AND CRITERIA GOVERNING TAX ABATEMENT INCENTIVES WITHIN THE CITY OF PARIS AND ITS EXTRATERRITORIAL JURISDICTION
RESOLUTION NO. 2004-165
A RESOLUTION OF THE, CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PARIS,
PARIS, TEXAS, ESTABLISHING GUIDELINES AND CRITERIA
GOVERNING TAX ABATEMENT INCENTIVES WITHIN THE CITY OF
PARIS AND ITS EXTRATERRITORIAL JURISDICTION; MAKING
OTHER FINDINGS AND PROVISIONS RELATED TO THE SUBJECT; AND
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Paris desires to promote economic development
within the corporate limits of the City of Paris and within its extraterritorial jurisdiction; and
WHEREAS, the provision of certain economic development incentives may encourage
prospective businesses and companies to locate within such corporate limits or extraterritorial
jurisdiction or existing businesses and companies located therein to expand; and,
WHEREAS, the establishment of specific guidelines, criteria, and procedures are necessary
to insure that tax abatement incentives are given and administered effectively; and,
WHEREAS, the adoption of guidelines and criteria are required by state law before an area
may be established as a reinvestment zone; NOW THEREFORE,
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PARIS, PARIS,
TEXAS:
Section 1. That the findings set out in the preamble to this resolution are hereby in all things
approved.
Section 2. That the City of Paris hereby establishes certain guidelines and criteria, attached
hereto as Exhibit A, governing tax abatement incentives within the City of Paris and its
extraterritorial jurisdiction, and such guidelines and criteria shall expressly govern all subsequent
tax abatement agreements in the City of Paris and its extraterritorial jurisdiction.
Section 3. That such guidelines and criteria shall be effective for two (2) years from the date
of adoption and may only be amended or repealed by a vote of three-fourths vote of the City council.
Section 4. That this resolution shall be effective from and after its date of passage.
PASSED AND APPROVED this 22nd day of September{{1.. .}14.
/'
iJ
.. ".,.
Curtis Fendley, Ma
~/
"";:-:~"
ATTEST:
CITY OF P ARIS, PARIS, TEXAS
GUIDELINES AND CRITERIA FOR
TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENTS
I. DEFINITIONS
a) "Abatement" means the full or partial exemption from ad valorem taxes of certain
real and tangible personal property in a Reinvestment Zone designated for economic
development purposes.
b) "Agreement" means the written agreement for tax Abatement between a property
owner and/or lessee and the City.
c) "Base Year Value" means the assessed value of eligible property as of January 1
preceding the date of execution of the Agreement plus the agreed upon value of
eligible property improvements made after January 1 but before the execution of the
Agreement.
d) "Enterprise Zone" means that area of the City d~signated as an enterprise zone under
the Texas Enterprise Zone Act (Texas Government Code Chapter 2303); where a
Reinvestment Zone as defined herein is also located in an Enterprise Zone, the
reference to Reinvestment Zone shall be interchangeable with Enterprise Zone.
e) "Manufacturing Facility" means buildings and structures, including fixed machinery
and equipment, the primary purpose of which is or will be the manufacture of
tangible goods or materials or the processing of such goods or materials by physical
or chemical change. Facilities primarily engaged in assembling component parts of
manufactured products are also considered manufacturing facilities.
f) "Modernization" means the replacement and upgrading of existing facilities which
increases the productive input or output, updates the technology, or substantially
lowers the unit cost of operation. Modernization may result from the construction,
alteration or installation of buildings, structures, fixed machinery or equipment, but
shall not be for the purpose of reconditioning, refurbishing, repairing, or deferred
maintenance.
g) "Other Basic Industry" means buildings and structures, including fixed machinery
and equipment, not elsewhere described, used, or to be used for the production of
products or services which result in the creation of new, permanent, full-time jobs
and bring new wealth into the community.
h) "Regional Distribution Facility" means buildings and structures, including fixed
machinery and equipment, used or to be used primarily to receive, store, service, or
-3-
EXHIBIT _
distribute goods or materials where a majority of the goods or services are distributed
to points at least 100 miles from its location in the City.
i) "Regional Tourist Entertainment Facility" means buildings and structures, including
fixed machinery and equipment, used or to be used in providing
amusement/entertainment through the admission of the general public where the
majority of users reside at least 100 miles from the City and where the majority of
users are likely to stay in the City for more than one day and will therefore likely
utilize local restaurants and hotel/motel accommodations.
j) "Reinvestment Zone" is an area where the City or County has decided to influence
development patterns and attract major investments that will contribute to the
development of the area through the use of tax Abatement for specified
improvements.
k) "Research Facility" means buildings and structures, including fixed machinery and
equipment, used or to be used primarily for research or experimentation to improve
or develop new tangible goods or materials or to improve or develop the production
processes thereto.
II. DESIGNATION OF A REINVESTMENT ZONE.
The City may designate an area as a Reinvestment Zone in accordance with the criteria and
procedural requirements set forth in the Property Redevelopment & Tax Abatement Act, as
amended (Chapter 312, Texas Tax Code).
III. TAX ABATEMENT AUTHORIZED.
The City, through its City Council, may agree in writing with the owner and/or lessee of
taxable real property that is located in a Reinvestment Zone, but that is not in an
improvement project financed by tax increment bonds, to exempt from taxation a portion of
the value of the real property, or of tangible personal property located on the real property,
or both. The period of the Abatement granted under the Agreement shall not exceed the term
authorized by law. Such Agreement will be based on the condition that the owner or lessee
of the property make specific improvements or repairs to the property. An Agreement may
provide for the exemption of the real property in each year covered by the Agreement only
to the extent its value for that year exceeds the Base Year Value. An Agreement may provide
for the exemption of tangible personal property located on the real property in each year
covered by the Agreement other than tangible personal property that was located on the real
property at any time before the period covered by the Agreement. Inventory or supplies
cannot be abated as tangible personal property.
-4-
A property owner and/or lessee shall be eligible for tax Abatement only upon the following
terms and conditions:
a) Authorized Facilities. A facility may be eligible for Abatement if it is a
Manufacturing Facility, Research Facility, Regional Distribution Facility, Regional
Tourist Entertainment Facility, or Other Basic Industry.
b) Creation of New Value. Abatement may only be granted for the additional value of
eligible real and tangible personal property improvements, subject to such limitations
as the City may require.
c) New and Existing Facilities. Abatement may be granted for new facilities and
improvements to existing facilities for purposes of modernization or expansion.
d) Eligible Property. Abatement may be extended to the value of buildings, structures,
fixed machinery and equipment, site improvements, tangible personal property, and
that office space and related fixed improvements necessary to the operation and
administration of the facility; provided, however, that inventory or supplies shall not
be eligible for Abatement.
e) Leased Facilities. Ifa leased facility is granted Abatement, the Agreement may be
executed with the lessor and/or lessee, depending upon the particular circumstances
of the proposed project. If the Agreement is with the lessor, lessor shall demonstrate
binding contracts with the lessee to guarantee compliance with the terms of the
Agreement.
f) Value and Term of Abatement. The City will decide whether to grant tax Abatement
to an applicant, and the amount, if any, of such Abatement, on a case-by-case basis.
The term of Abatement granted under any Agreement may not exceed that permitted
by applicable state law. The amount of the Abatement shall be based upon a
percentage (0 to 100%) of all or a portion of the eligible property. Abatement may
only be granted for the additional value of eligible property improvements made
pursuant to and listed in the Agreement between the City and property owner and/or
lessee subject to such limitations as the City may require. If a modernization project
includes facility replacement, the value eligible for Abatement shall be the value of
the new unites), less the value of the replaced unites). The criteria that will be used
in evaluating a particular application for Abatement will include, but not be limited
to:
1) the dollar amount of the increase in the tax roll for the proposed project;
2) the number of jobs created by the proposed project;
-5-
3) the possible effect the proposed project will have on attracting other taxable
improvements into the City;
4) the nature of the proposed project and its overall effect on the community;
5) the proposed project's effect on the safety, health, and morals of the City's
residents;
6) whether the proposed project will have any substantial long-term adverse
effect on the provision of the City's services or its tax base;
7) whether the project meets all relevant zoning requirements;
8) whether the project is consistent with the comprehensive plan of the City of
Paris or County of Lamar; and
9) the types and cost of public improvements and services (water and sewer
main extensions, streets and alleys, etc.) required of the City and the types
and values of public improvements to be furnished by the applicant.
g) Economic Qualification. In order to be eligible to receive tax Abatement, the
planned improvements:
I) must be reasonably expected to increase the appraised value of the property;
AND
2) must be expected to prevent the loss of employment, retain, or create
employment on a permanent, full-time basis in the City during the term of the
Agreement; AND
3) should not be expected to solely or primarily have the effect of merely
transferring existing employment from one part of the City to another without
demonstration of increased future investment (Dollars or jobs) or unusual
circumstances whereby without such a move employment is likely to be
reduced; AND
4) must be necessary because capacity cannot be provided efficiently utilizing
existing improved property, even when reasonable allowance is made for
necessary improvements or relevant governmental actions.
h) Taxability. During the term of the Agreement, taxes shall be payable as follows:
1) the Base Year Value of eligible property as determined each year shall be
-6-
fully taxable; and
2) the additional value of eligible property above the Base Year Value shall be
taxable in the manner described in the Agreement.
The Chief Appraiser of the City shall annually determine an assessment of the real
and personal property comprising the Reinvestment Zone. Each year, the company
or individual receiving Abatement pursuant to an Agreement shall furnish the
assessor with such information as may be necessary to determine the amount of any
Abatement. Once such value has been established, the Chief Appraiser shall notify
the affected jurisdictions which levy taxes on such property.
IV. APPLICATION.
a) Eligibility. Any present or potential owner of taxable property in the City may
request tax Abatement by filing a written request with the City Manager.
b) Form. The application shall consist of a completed application form accompanied
by (i) general description of the improvements to be undertaken together with the
projected new value to the property and the type of business operation proposed; (ii)
descriptive list of the improvements for which an Abatement is requested; (iii) list
of the kind, number, and location of all proposed improvements of the property; (iv)
the number and type of jobs created, including information pertaining to anticipated
job transfers; (v) metes and bounds description and plat of the proposed
Reinvestment Zone that shows all roadways within 200 feet of the site and all
existing zoning and land uses within 200 feet of the site; (vi) time schedule for
undertaking and completing the proposed improvements; (vii) the type and value of
any economic development incentives requested; and, (viii) any other information
about the proposed project as may be required by the City or as deemed desirable.
c) Review. Once the Application has been received, the information submitted will be
reviewed by the City Manager for completeness and accuracy. The City Manager
will then distribute the Application to the appropriate department heads for internal
review and comments. Following staff review, copies of the complete Application
package and staff comments will be provided to the City Council and to other taxing
entities that may be willing to participate in offering tax abatement incentives.
Generally, the City Council, staff, and other taxing entities will discuss the proposed
Application at a work session prior to its formal consideration by the City Council.
Following the work session, the City Manager may be requested to obtain other
information prior to further consideration of the Application.
At a subsequent regular City Council meeting, the Application for any tax Abatement
incentive may be considered. Prior to final approval, all legal documents to effect
such Reinvestment Zone(s) and tax Abatement Agreement(s) shall be drafted and
-7-
approved by the City Attorney.
d) Public Hearing. The City will comply with certain public notices and hearings
required as mandated by state law under the Property Redevelopment and Tax
Abatement Act prior to the designation of a reinvestment zone and execution of a tax
abatement agreement.
e) Findings. In order to enter into an Agreement, the City Council must find that (i) the
terms of the proposed Agreement comply with these Guidelines and Criteria, (ii)
there will be no substantial adverse affect on the provision of the City's services or
tax base, and (iii) the planned use of the property will not constitute a hazard to
public safety, health, or morals.
f) Variances. Requests for variance from the provisions of these Guidelines may be
made in writing to the City Manager; provided, however, that in no event shall the
term of any Abatement exceed the period authorized by applicable state law. Such
request shall include a complete description of the circumstances requiring a
variance. Approval of a request for variance shall require the affirmative vote of
three-fourths (3/4) of the members of the City Council.
v. AGREEMENT. After approval, the City Council shall formally pass an order or resolution
and authorize the execution of an Agreement with the owner and/or lessee of the facility
which shall include; but not be limited to, the following terms:
a) the Base Year Value;
b) percent of increased value to be abated each year;
c) the commencement date and the termination date of Abatement;
d) amount of investment and average number of jobs involved during the term of the
Agreement;
e) the proposed use of the facility, nature of construction, time schedule, plat, property
description, and improvement list, as provided in the Application;
f) a listing ofthe kind, number, location, and costs of all proposed improvements of the
property;
g) a statement limiting the uses of the property consistent with the general purpose of
encouraging development or redevelopment of the zone during the period that
property tax exemptions are in effect;
-8-
h) that access to the project be provided to allow for the inspection by City inspectors
and officials in order to ensure that the improvements or repairs are made according
to the specifications and conditions of the agreement;
i) that property tax revenue lost as a result of the tax abatement agreement will be
recaptured by the City if the owner of the property fails to make the improvements
or repairs as provided by the agreement;
j) each term agreed to by the owner of the property;
k) a requirement that the owner of the property shall certify annually to the City Council
that the owner is in compliance with each applicable term of the agreement;
1) contractual obligations in the event of default, violation of terms or conditions,
delinquent taxes, recapture, administration and assignment, or other provisions that
may be required by state law, or in the discretion of the City Council; and
m) that the City Council may cancel or modify the agreement if the property owner fails
to comply with the agreement.
VI. DEFAULT. If the City determines that the person or entity receiving an Abatement is in
default according to the terms and conditions of its Agreement, the City shall notify the
company or individual in writing at the address stated in the Agreement, and if such default
is not cured within a reasonable period oftime specified in such notice ("Cure Period"), then
the Agreement may be modified or terminated without further notice.
In the event that the company or individual (i) allows its ad valorem taxes owed the City to
become delinquent and fails to timely and properly follow the legal procedures for their
protest and/or contest, or (ii) violates any of the terms and conditions ofthe Agreement and
fails to cure during the Cure Period, the Agreement then may be modified or terminated
without further notice, and the Agreement may provide a formula for recapture of all or part
of the taxes abated.
VII. CONFIDENTIALITY OF PROPRIETARY INFORMATION. Information that is
provided to a taxing unit in connection with an application or request for tax Abatement
under these Guidelines and that describes the specific processes or business activities to be
conducted or the equipment or other property to be located on the property for which tax
Abatement is sought is confidential and not subject to public disclosure unless otherwise
mandated by state law until the Agreement is executed. Such information in the custody of
the City after the Agreement is executed is not confidential under these Guidelines.
VIII. PROPOSED TAX ABATEMENT AGREEMENTS TO BE DECIDED ON AN
INDIVIDUAL BASIS. The adoption of these Guidelines by the City Council does not (i)
-9-
limit the discretion of the City Council to decide whether to enter into a specific tax
Abatement agreement, or (ii) limit the discretion of the City to delegate to its employees the
authority to determine whether or not the City Council should consider a particular
application or request for tax Abatement, or (iii) create any property, contract, or other legal
right in any person or entity to have the City Council consider or grant a specific application
or request for tax Abatement.
IX. INSPECTIONS. The Agreement shall stipulate that employees and/or designated
representatives of the City will have access to the Reinvestment Zone during the term of the
Agreement to inspect the facility to determine if the terms and conditions of the Agreement
are being met. All inspections will be made only after the giving of at least twenty-four (24)
hours' prior notice and will only be conducted in such manner as to not unreasonably
interfere with the construction and/or operation of the facility. All inspections will be made
with one or more representatives of the company or individual and in accordance with its
safety standards.
Upon completion of construction, the City shall annually evaluate each facility receiving
Abatement to ensure compliance with the Agreement and report possible violations of the
Agreement to the City Council.
x. MODIFICATIONS OF AGREEMENT. At any time before the expiration of an
Agreement made under these Guidelines, the Agreement may be modified by the parties to
the Agreement to include other provisions that could have been included in the original
Agreement or to delete provisions that were contained in the original Agreement. The
modification must be made by the same procedure by which the original Agreement was
approved and executed. The original Agreement, however, may not be modified to extend
the term of the Agreement or the term of the Abatement granted therein beyond the time
permitted by state law.
XI. ASSIGNMENT. An Agreement may be assigned to a new owner or lessee of the facility
only with the prior written consent of the City. Any assignment shall provide that the
assignee shall irrevocably and unconditionally assume all the duties and obligations of the
assignor upon the same terms and conditions as set out in the Agreement, and the City's
approval shall be subject to the determination of the financial capability of such assignee.
Any assignment of an Agreement shall be to an entity that contemplates the same
improvements or repairs to the property, except to the extent such improvements or repairs
have been completed. No assignment shall be approved if the assignor or the assignee are
indebted to the City for ad valorem taxes or other obligations, or if any event of default under
the Agreement remains uncured.
XII. AMENDMENTS. These Guidelines are effective for two (2) a year period from the date
of their adoption, unless amended or repealed by the affirmative vote of three-fourths (3/4)
of the members of the City Council.
-10-