04-B Hutchison AppearanceAGENDA INFORMATION SHEET
PROJECT: Request for pro rata participation on the extension of Pine Mill Road from 30th Street N. E. to
Collegiate Drive.
BACKGROUND: Mr. Brad Hutchison has presented a letter to the City of Paris requesting the City to
participate pro rata in the cost of extending Pine Mill Road from 30th Street N. E. to Collegiate Drive.
This circumstance is apparently one similar to a circumstance which City Council will recall involving
Brownstone Development Corporation. At that time, the City was asked to participate in the pro rata cost of
the sizing of the street in the Brownstone Development on the basis of prior communications and discussions
between officials of Brownstone and former City Engineer Earl Smith. Following a review of the facts and
information provided by Brownstone, City Council determined there had been a tacit understanding between
the City and Brownstone for pro-rata assistance from the City.
Mr. Hutchison is requesting similar assistance on behalf of his clients for this road extension, on much the same
basis as the request by Brownstone. That is, there were apparently discussions between then City Engineer
Earl Smith and one or more of Mr. Hutchison's clients regarding the City paying part of the cost of extending
this road.
By way of further background information, extending Pine Mill Road is shown on the City master plan, but
would not be required to be sized as shown on the master plan simply to accommodate the traffic generated
by the anticipated development.
Pro-rata assistance for streets is authorized under Section VII (11) of the City Subdivision Regulations under
the following circumstances:
"Standard street width. The standard street width in which the subdivider shall be required to
construct all street and drainage improvements shall be that of a collector street, i.e., thirty-nine
(39) feet from back of curb to back of curb. All street paving over this width shall be subject
to participating aid from the city as set forth in this ordinance."
City Council will recall that following the consideration of the Brownstone Development matter, the
subdivision regulations were amended to require a written request for pro rata assistance and a written
approval by the City Engineer before pro rata assistance was appropriate. However, this matter apparently
arose between the City and Mr. Hutchison's clients prior to the amendment of the subdivision regulations.
DESCRIPTION: Consider action on the request for pro rata participation by the City in the cost of the
extension of Pine Mill Road from 30th Street N. E. to Collegiate Drive.
COST: The exact cost is at this point unknown, but presumably it would represent the additional cost of the
developer building a street larger than a simple local street, which has a maximum paving width of twenty-eight
feet (28').
LOCATION: Pine Mill Road will be extended from 30th Street N. E. to Collegiate Drive.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Provide direction to the City staff as to whether or not the City should
participate in the pro rata cost of the extension of this street.
STAFF CONTACT: Shawn Napier, City Engineer; Larry W. Schenk, City Attorney; and Michael E. Malone
City Manager
SCHEDtlLE: The developers are most anxious to proceed with their development, and need direction as to
whether or not the City will participate in the pro rata cost of the street.
CO[INCIL DATE: Consider at City Council's November 12, 2001, regular Council meeting.
ADDITIONAL MATERIALS: See attached correspondence from attorney Brad Hutchison of the law firm
of McLaughlin, Hutchison & Hunt.
J. D MCLAUGhLIN
BRAD HUTCH~SON
THOMAS E. HUNT ]]~
MCLAUGHLIN, HUTCHISON &
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
38 FIRST STREET NORTHWEST
PARIS, TEXAS 75460
HUNT
(903
FAX(903
October 22, 2001
Mr. La..,'ry W. Schemk
City Attorney
City of Paris
City Hall Annex
Pads, Texas 75460
RE: Extension of Pine Mill Road
Dear Mr. Schenk:
In September of 2000, H-W Investments, Ted L. McLemore and Earl Bellamy closed an
exchange of lands whereby Ted McLemore became the owner of Lot 14-A of City Block :!59. As
a part of that contract, those three parties agreed to pay certain costs incident to the constnction of
the street and curb and gutter for the extension of Pine Mill Road from 31 st NE wes~ ward to
Collegiate Drive. At the time it was their understanding that the City of Paris would pay 1/39ths
of the total costs of the street, curb and gutter for said extension.
Those parties are now ready to begin the extension of Pine Mill Road, but prior to.rtceiving
bids they need a written commitment from the City that it will pay its 11/39ths of the tota~ cost of
the extension. This letter represents their formal request for such a written commitment from the
City of Paris.
McLAUGHLIN, HUTCHISON & HUNT
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
38 FIRST STREET NORTHWEST
October 24, 2001
Mr. Larry W. Schenk
City Attorney
City of Paris
City Hall Annex
Paris, Texas 75460
RE: Extension of Pine Mill Road
Dear Mr. Schenk:
My letter of October 22, 2001, to you concerning the extension of Pine Mill R
mistake. The extension is from 30th NE westward to Collegiate. I attach a copy of the I
when writing my letter and you will see that it calls the street in question 31 st NE, but i
30th NE.
Please adjust your response to my letter accordingly.
~ad has a
ilat I used
is in fact
encl.
~v:'
Tow~ No~h Estates
Investments
~70'
.
ne MHI Rood
ot ~ 1~C ~ lot
~ ~ SL
~ . fence 1= 200' pp power pole J.M. NeJsorl, RPL-~ of Tex=s. ~025 dot~
= = ~
~ ~pp~ Iron pm
9~ ~ Me ~ P~ Te~ 7~0
EXHIBIT ~, ..