|
1. The chairman called the meeting to order at 4:03 P.M.
<br />2. The minutes of the July 11, 2018 meeting were approved by acclamation.
<br />3. Discussion and possible action on the following Certificates of Appropriateness
<br />HD -I5 418 W Washington, Wise House -Roof replacement, Justin Vickers
<br />Mr. Vickers appeared as the representative of the property owner, and is the caretaker of the house. He
<br />stated there were multiple leaks in the roof and it was doing damage to the interior of the house. He stated
<br />that the owner of the property had investigated the use of the cedar shingles, and the option was not only
<br />costprohibitive, but the owners had a lot trouble finding anyone who would install the cedar shingles, nor
<br />would any insurance companies insure the property with cedar shingles. The owner is requesting to put
<br />on a high profile shingle, similar to the historic home across the street, in the color green.
<br />Chairman Dux spoke to the fact that waterpenetrating the roof is the quickest way to destroy a building.
<br />He gave Mr. Vickers a copy of an article on the advantages, disadvantages and cost comparison of
<br />different type roofs and longevity and asked him to review it, along with the NPS preservation briefs on
<br />wooden roofs before he replaces the roof. He also advised that the asphalt shingles will diminish the value
<br />of the property the minute it is put on.
<br />Commissioner Hider made the motion to approve the use of the Timberline high definition asphalt
<br />shingles in hunter green, seconded by Commissioner Lazar. Chairman Dux made an amendment that the
<br />shingles be approved with the shingles presented or a higher profile, due to the importance to the
<br />character of the structure, in which Commissioner Hider agreed. With no other discussion, a call for a
<br />vote was made. Motion carried S - 0
<br />B. 507 S. Church, replacement siding, Hunter Moore
<br />Mr. Moore explained that his house was built in the late 1800's and was a two story house, but the second
<br />story was remove at some point, creating some roof lines that dump excessive water on the west facing
<br />facade of the house and causing deterioration of the current siding. Mr Moore proposed to replace it with
<br />cedar shingles as an accent siding, and painting it with the appropriate color. He noted examples of cedar on
<br />the existing carriage house that belongs with the property, and on the neighboring house.
<br />Mr. Moore further explained that the type of siding that is currently on the house is no longer available, and
<br />the more modern type of this siding doesn't have the same profile. Mr. Moore researched the wood mill in
<br />REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
<br />CITY OF PARIS HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
<br />CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
<br />WEDNESDAY AUGUST 8. 2018
<br />............
<br />Present:
<br />_................. �-
<br />Absent:
<br />Chris Dux, Chairman
<br />Matt Coyle, Vice Chairman
<br />Randy Hider, Secretary
<br />Sarah Barbee
<br />Linda Vandiver
<br />Glee Emmite
<br />Guests:
<br />Mike Lazar
<br />Justin Vickers
<br />Hunter and Kelli Moore
<br />Linda Knox, Council liaison
<br />Janet and Keith Green
<br />Cheri Bedford, HPO
<br />Paul Denney
<br />John Godwin, City Manager
<br />Barbara Wilson
<br />1. The chairman called the meeting to order at 4:03 P.M.
<br />2. The minutes of the July 11, 2018 meeting were approved by acclamation.
<br />3. Discussion and possible action on the following Certificates of Appropriateness
<br />HD -I5 418 W Washington, Wise House -Roof replacement, Justin Vickers
<br />Mr. Vickers appeared as the representative of the property owner, and is the caretaker of the house. He
<br />stated there were multiple leaks in the roof and it was doing damage to the interior of the house. He stated
<br />that the owner of the property had investigated the use of the cedar shingles, and the option was not only
<br />costprohibitive, but the owners had a lot trouble finding anyone who would install the cedar shingles, nor
<br />would any insurance companies insure the property with cedar shingles. The owner is requesting to put
<br />on a high profile shingle, similar to the historic home across the street, in the color green.
<br />Chairman Dux spoke to the fact that waterpenetrating the roof is the quickest way to destroy a building.
<br />He gave Mr. Vickers a copy of an article on the advantages, disadvantages and cost comparison of
<br />different type roofs and longevity and asked him to review it, along with the NPS preservation briefs on
<br />wooden roofs before he replaces the roof. He also advised that the asphalt shingles will diminish the value
<br />of the property the minute it is put on.
<br />Commissioner Hider made the motion to approve the use of the Timberline high definition asphalt
<br />shingles in hunter green, seconded by Commissioner Lazar. Chairman Dux made an amendment that the
<br />shingles be approved with the shingles presented or a higher profile, due to the importance to the
<br />character of the structure, in which Commissioner Hider agreed. With no other discussion, a call for a
<br />vote was made. Motion carried S - 0
<br />B. 507 S. Church, replacement siding, Hunter Moore
<br />Mr. Moore explained that his house was built in the late 1800's and was a two story house, but the second
<br />story was remove at some point, creating some roof lines that dump excessive water on the west facing
<br />facade of the house and causing deterioration of the current siding. Mr Moore proposed to replace it with
<br />cedar shingles as an accent siding, and painting it with the appropriate color. He noted examples of cedar on
<br />the existing carriage house that belongs with the property, and on the neighboring house.
<br />Mr. Moore further explained that the type of siding that is currently on the house is no longer available, and
<br />the more modern type of this siding doesn't have the same profile. Mr. Moore researched the wood mill in
<br />
|